When a party refuses to close on a Florida real estate contract, the non-breaching party generally has three avenues: specific performance to compel the sale, damages, or recovery of the deposit. Which is realistic depends on the contract language, whether a contingency was properly exercised, and whether the agreement satisfies Florida’s Statute of Frauds, Fla. Stat. § 725.01.
The First Question Is Not What You Are Owed
When a deal collapses the instinct is to ask what the other side owes you. The more useful first question is narrower: was there an enforceable contract, and did the other side actually breach it?
Florida’s Statute of Frauds, Fla. Stat. § 725.01, generally requires that a contract for the sale of land be in writing and signed by the party to be charged. Agreements that cannot be performed within one year are covered as well. A handshake, an email chain that never resolved into signatures, or an oral promise to sell is frequently unenforceable, and that single rule disposes of a surprising number of disputes before anyone reaches the merits.
Assuming a signed contract exists, the next question is whether the other side breached or simply exercised a right the contract gave them. Residential purchase agreements in Florida typically contain contingencies — financing, inspection, appraisal, sale of an existing home — and a buyer who properly and timely exercises one has not breached anything. Most disputes we see turn on whether a contingency was invoked within its window and in the manner the contract required.
Specific Performance: Making the Sale Happen
Real property is treated as unique in the eyes of the law, which is why real estate is one of the areas where courts will order a party to perform rather than simply pay. A buyer who wants the particular house, not a cheque, can seek specific performance compelling the seller to convey it.
This is an equitable remedy, which means it is discretionary. A court weighs whether the claimant is ready, willing, and able to perform their own side, whether the contract terms are sufficiently definite to enforce, and whether ordering performance would be inequitable in the circumstances.
Practical point: a buyer pursuing specific performance should expect to show they can actually close — proof of funds or financing matters. And because litigation takes time while the seller may try to sell elsewhere, a lis pendens recorded under Fla. Stat. § 48.23 is often filed to give notice that the property is the subject of pending litigation. A lis pendens must be supported by the pleadings; an improperly recorded one can be discharged and can carry consequences for the party who filed it.
Damages and the Deposit
Where performance is not the goal — or not available — the claim becomes one for damages. A buyer’s damages often centre on the difference between the contract price and the property’s value, plus costs incurred in reliance on the deal. A seller’s damages may involve a resale at a lower price, carrying costs, and the expense of putting the property back on the market.
The deposit is usually the most immediate fight. Most Florida contracts specify what happens to escrowed funds on default, and many give a seller the choice between retaining the deposit as liquidated damages and suing for actual damages. Read that clause before taking a position, because electing one route can foreclose the other.
Where an escrow agent holds disputed funds, the agent cannot simply hand them to whoever asks. A licensed real estate broker holding the deposit has statutory obligations that include notifying the Florida Real Estate Commission of a dispute and then following one of several defined routes — mediation, arbitration, an escrow disbursement order, or an interpleader action depositing the funds with the court. The practical consequence for the parties is that the money sits still until the dispute is resolved.
Attorney’s Fees Often Decide Strategy
Florida follows the American Rule: each side generally bears its own attorney’s fees unless a contract or statute shifts them. Most residential and commercial real estate contracts contain a prevailing-party fee clause, which changes the economics of a modest dispute in both directions.
That clause is worth reading before anything else. A disagreement over a $20,000 deposit looks very different when the losing party may also pay both sides’ fees. It is a reason some claims are worth pursuing that would otherwise not be, and a reason others should be settled early.
Deadlines
An action on a written contract in Florida must generally be brought within five years; an oral contract, generally four. Those are outside limits, not targets. Evidence in a failed transaction — emails, texts, inspection reports, the agent’s file — degrades quickly, and a lis pendens is only useful while the property has not already been sold on to someone else.
If a closing has collapsed, the sensible step is to gather the contract, every addendum, and the full communication record now, while it still exists.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I force the other side to go through with the sale?
Possibly. Because real property is treated as unique, Florida courts can order specific performance compelling a sale. It is an equitable, discretionary remedy, and a buyer seeking it should expect to show they are ready, willing, and able to close.
Who gets the deposit if the deal falls apart?
It depends on the contract and on who breached. Most Florida contracts specify how escrowed funds are handled on default, and many let a seller choose between keeping the deposit as liquidated damages and suing for actual damages. Where the deposit is disputed and held by a broker, it generally stays put until the dispute is resolved through one of the defined routes.
Is a verbal agreement to sell a house enforceable in Florida?
Generally no. Fla. Stat. § 725.01, Florida’s Statute of Frauds, requires contracts for the sale of land to be in writing and signed by the party to be charged. This single rule resolves many disputes before the merits are reached.
What is a lis pendens and should I file one?
A lis pendens is a recorded notice under Fla. Stat. § 48.23 that real property is the subject of pending litigation, which warns off later purchasers. It must be supported by the pleadings — an unsupported notice can be discharged and can expose the filer to consequences, so it is not something to record casually.
How long do I have to sue?
An action on a written contract in Florida must generally be brought within five years, and on an oral contract generally four. Those are outer limits; evidence and practical options both deteriorate well before then.
