Under Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985), a Florida residential seller must disclose known facts that materially affect the property's value and are not readily observable by the buyer. An "AS IS" clause does not license concealment of known latent defects. Remedies may include rescission, damages, and fraud claims.
The Rule Florida Sellers Must Follow
Florida's disclosure duty comes from a 1985 Florida Supreme Court decision, Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625. The court held that where a seller of a home knows of facts materially affecting the value of the property which are not readily observable and are not known to the buyer, the seller has a duty to disclose them.
Three elements do the work in that sentence, and every nondisclosure case turns on them. The seller must have known. The defect must materially affect value. And it must not have been readily observable — meaning a reasonable inspection would not have revealed it.
A defect the seller genuinely did not know about is generally not actionable under this duty. A crack plainly visible on a walkthrough generally is not either. The claims that succeed involve something hidden and something known.
"Sold AS IS" Is Not a Shield for Concealment
This is the most common misunderstanding we encounter, from buyers and sellers alike.
An AS IS clause allocates the risk of the property's condition — it tells the buyer not to expect repairs and to rely on their own inspection. What it does not do is give a seller license to actively conceal or affirmatively misrepresent a known latent defect.
So a buyer who discovers a problem that a competent inspection should have caught usually has no claim in an AS IS deal. A buyer who discovers that the seller painted over a persistent leak, or answered a direct written question falsely, may well have one.
Defects That Commonly Give Rise to Claims
Water intrusion and roof leaks — particularly where cosmetic repairs were made to hide staining.
Prior flooding or repeated drainage problems not visible in dry conditions.
Structural movement, settlement, or sinkhole activity, including prior remediation.
Unpermitted work. Additions, enclosures, or electrical and plumbing changes done without permits — often discovered only when the buyer later tries to permit their own work.
Termite or pest damage and prior treatment history.
Undisclosed association problems — pending special assessments, litigation, or reserve shortfalls.
Defective materials and known manufacturer or building-material issues affecting the structure.
What You Can Recover
Rescission unwinds the sale where the misrepresentation goes to the heart of the bargain — a remedy that is harder to obtain the longer you have lived in and altered the property.
Damages are more common: typically the cost to repair, or the difference between what you paid and what the property was actually worth given the defect.
Fraud claims may be available where the seller affirmatively lied rather than merely stayed silent, and these can open additional categories of recovery.
Timing matters. Claims sounding in fraud generally run from when the problem was or reasonably should have been discovered, but waiting makes proof of the seller's prior knowledge harder — repair records go cold and witnesses move on.
| Issue | Florida position |
|---|---|
| Controlling case | Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985) |
| What must be disclosed | Known facts materially affecting value, not readily observable |
| Effect of AS IS | Allocates condition risk; does not permit concealment of known latent defects |
| Typical remedies | Rescission, repair-cost or diminution damages, fraud claims |
| Key evidence | Prior repair records, permits, insurance claims, seller communications |
Matters We Handle
- Undisclosed water intrusion, roof, and drainage defects
- Concealed structural, settlement, and sinkhole history
- Unpermitted additions and code-compliance problems
- Undisclosed association assessments, litigation, and reserve shortfalls
- Misrepresentations on seller disclosure forms
- Rescission and damages actions against sellers
- Claims involving agents and brokers where warranted
Frequently Asked Questions
The house was sold "AS IS" — do I still have a claim?
Possibly. An AS IS clause allocates the risk of the property's condition and defeats claims about problems a reasonable inspection should have revealed. It does not permit a seller to actively conceal, or lie about, a known latent defect. If the seller knew of a hidden problem and hid it or misstated it, the AS IS clause is generally not a complete answer.
How do I prove the seller actually knew?
Rarely by confession — usually by records. Prior repair invoices, insurance claims, permit history, HOA correspondence, prior listing photographs or descriptions, and communications with agents and neighbors all build the picture. This is why acting promptly matters: those records are easier to obtain before they go stale.
Does the duty apply to commercial property too?
The Johnson v. Davis duty arose in the residential context, and its application outside residential transactions is more limited and fact-dependent. Commercial buyers more often rely on negotiated representations and warranties in the contract itself. If your purchase was commercial, the analysis starts with what the agreement actually promised.
How long do I have to bring a nondisclosure claim?
It depends on the legal theory. Claims sounding in fraud generally run from when the defect was or reasonably should have been discovered, which can extend the window. But delay weakens proof of the seller's knowledge, so the practical deadline is often shorter than the legal one. Confirm the applicable period with an attorney promptly.
Bring the contract, deed, or lease and we will tell you candidly where you stand — including when a claim is not worth pursuing. Consultations are free and confidential.
Schedule Free Consultation