Real Estate Litigation

Florida Specific Performance Attorney

When a seller refuses to close, money damages may not be enough — you wanted the property. Specific performance asks a court to order the sale completed.

Free Consultation Call (954) 417.7000
Argued before the Florida Supreme Court Clear, upfront fees Free consultation Se habla español
Short answer

Specific performance is a court order compelling a party to complete a real estate sale rather than simply pay damages. Florida courts grant it because each parcel of land is treated as unique, so money is often an inadequate substitute. It requires an enforceable written contract and a buyer ready, willing, and able to perform.

Why Real Estate Is Different

In most contract disputes, the law's preferred remedy is money. Courts assume you can take damages and buy a substitute. Real estate is the classic exception: each parcel sits in a particular location with a particular view, lot, and set of characteristics that cannot be replicated by buying something else.

That principle is why specific performance — an extraordinary remedy in most commercial contexts — is realistically available in Florida real estate disputes. A buyer who genuinely wanted that property is not made whole by a check.

What You Must Establish

A specific performance claim generally turns on several elements, and weakness in any one of them is where these cases are won or lost.

An enforceable written contract. Because of Florida's Statute of Frauds, an oral agreement to sell land is generally unenforceable. The writing must identify the parties, the property, and the essential terms.

Your own readiness to perform. This is where buyers most often stumble. A court will not order a seller to convey to a buyer who cannot close. Proof of funds, a firm loan commitment, or evidence you tendered performance matters enormously.

The other side's refusal. A clear demand and a clear refusal, documented in writing, makes the case materially stronger.

Equitable conduct on your part. Specific performance is an equitable remedy, so defenses like unclean hands, unreasonable delay, or your own prior breach can defeat it.

Lis Pendens: Protecting the Property While You Litigate

A specific performance claim is worth little if the seller sells to someone else while the case is pending. Florida's lis pendens statute (Fla. Stat. § 48.23) allows a party in a lawsuit affecting title to record notice in the county's public records.

Once recorded, anyone who later acquires an interest in the property takes it subject to the outcome of the lawsuit. As a practical matter, it makes the property very difficult to sell or finance while the case proceeds.

A lis pendens is powerful and therefore scrutinized. A court can discharge one that is not supported by the pleadings, and an improperly recorded notice can expose the filer to liability. It is not something to record casually.

What the Other Side Will Argue

Expect a seller to attack the contract itself — that an essential term was never agreed, that a condition was unmet, or that the writing fails the Statute of Frauds.

Expect them to attack your readiness — that you could not actually have closed, which converts the case into a damages claim at best.

Expect delay arguments — that you sat on your rights while circumstances changed. Moving promptly matters, both legally and practically.

Key facts
IssueFlorida position
What it doesCourt order compelling completion of the sale
Why availableReal property is treated as unique; damages often inadequate
Key requirementBuyer ready, willing, and able to close
Protective toolNotice of lis pendens — Fla. Stat. § 48.23
Nature of remedyEquitable — subject to equitable defenses

Matters We Handle

  • Buyer actions to compel a refusing seller to convey
  • Seller actions to compel a defaulting buyer to complete purchase
  • Recording and defending notices of lis pendens
  • Motions to discharge improperly recorded lis pendens
  • Commercial and investment property enforcement
  • Option and right-of-first-refusal enforcement

Frequently Asked Questions

How quickly do I need to act?

Promptly. Specific performance is an equitable remedy, and unreasonable delay is a recognized defense — a seller will argue you waited while the market moved. There is also a practical reason: until a lis pendens is recorded, nothing stops the property being sold to someone else. Speaking with an attorney within days rather than months materially improves your position.

What is a lis pendens and do I need one?

It is a recorded notice that a lawsuit affecting title to the property is pending, authorized by Fla. Stat. § 48.23. Anyone acquiring an interest afterward takes subject to the outcome, which as a practical matter makes the property very hard to sell or finance. It is often essential in these cases — but courts can discharge an unsupported one, and improper recording can create liability, so it should be filed with care.

Can a seller be forced to sell if they simply changed their mind?

A change of mind is generally not a legal excuse for non-performance. If there is an enforceable written contract, you were ready to close, and no contractual condition relieved the seller, a change of heart is ordinarily no defense. The analysis still depends on the contract's specific terms and any conditions that were or were not satisfied.

What if I also lost money because of the delay?

Specific performance and damages are not always mutually exclusive. A court ordering the sale to close may also award compensation for losses caused by the delay — additional carrying costs, temporary housing, or rate changes, where provable. What is recoverable depends on the contract and the facts.

Please note: This page is general legal information, not legal advice. Florida real estate law turns heavily on the specific contract, deed, lease, or policy language involved, and on dates that vary from matter to matter. No attorney-client relationship is created by reading this page or contacting the firm — that requires a signed engagement agreement. RNC Legal's bona fide office is at 200 South Andrews Avenue, Suite 503, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, with an additional location in Wilton Manors. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Discuss Your Matter

Bring the contract, deed, or lease and we will tell you candidly where you stand — including when a claim is not worth pursuing. Consultations are free and confidential.

Schedule Free Consultation

Florida Real Estate Disputes

From breached purchase contracts to title defects and lease disputes, RNC Legal represents owners, buyers, sellers, investors, and associations across Florida.

Free consultation · Confidential · Bilingual (En/Es)